Abhishek Banerjee Responds to Calcutta High Court Show-Cause Notice
Kolkata: Trinamool Congress MP Abhishek Banerjee responded to the Calcutta High Court show-cause notice on Tuesday, saying he had never claimed that any judge was a member of the BJP but had alleged that a section of the judiciary was functioning under political pressure.
The Calcutta High Court initiated criminal contempt proceedings against Banerjee on November 17 and directed him to explain within 15 days why punishment should not be imposed over remarks concerning judges and the judicial process. The matter is scheduled to be heard again on December 8.
Banerjee Clarifies Remarks on Judiciary
Speaking in Kolkata, Banerjee said his earlier remarks had been misinterpreted.
He maintained that he had spoken about a section of the judiciary being under political influence but had never said that any individual judge belonged to the BJP.
Banerjee also acknowledged that many judges remain impartial, while arguing that judicial neutrality must be reflected consistently in how different political leaders and cases are treated.
His comments represent his political and legal position; the High Court has not accepted those allegations as established fact.
Calcutta High Court Initiates Contempt Proceedings
Justice Krishna Rao initiated the criminal contempt proceedings after considering remarks made by Banerjee while his petition challenging the reduction of his security cover was pending before the court.
The High Court said the statements prima facie amounted to interference with the administration of justice and directed that a show-cause notice be served on him.
The controversy arose during proceedings concerning Banerjee’s challenge to the downgrade of his security from Z-plus to X category.
Separately, the court directed the West Bengal Home and Hill Affairs Department to convene a review committee meeting within two weeks to reconsider his request for enhanced security.
Banerjee Alleges Different Standards
Banerjee argued that opposition politicians were not always treated in the same manner as BJP leaders when making controversial comments about courts or judicial institutions.
He referred to remarks previously made by BJP MP Nishikant Dubey and Suvendu Adhikari and questioned why, in his view, similar contempt proceedings had not followed.
He also alleged that cases involving BJP leaders sometimes receive different judicial treatment from those involving opposition figures.
These were allegations made by Banerjee, not findings by the court.
Says Judicial Neutrality Should Be Visible
Banerjee said his broader concern was about what he described as a “double standard” and argued that if the judiciary is neutral, that impartiality should be evident through its actions.
The High Court, however, has taken the view at this stage that his earlier remarks warrant an explanation under contempt law.
A show-cause notice is an initial procedural step and does not by itself amount to a final finding that Banerjee is guilty of criminal contempt. He has been given an opportunity to respond before further consideration by the court.
The next hearing in the contempt matter is scheduled for December 8, 2026.
Comments (0)